Donor-Advised Funds: You Got the Tax Deduction, But Who Controls the Money?

For philanthropically minded individuals in Tucker, Georgia, and nationwide, donor-advised funds (DAFs) have long been the gold standard for charitable giving. They offer a highly effective way to support causes you care about while maximizing your financial strategy. You can contribute appreciated assets, secure an immediate tax deduction, avoid capital gains, and decide later where the money ultimately goes.

However, a recent legal dispute involving a $21 million fund is shedding light on a critical nuance many donors overlook: once you fund a donor-advised account, the money is no longer legally yours.

The Mechanics Behind the DAF Boom

A donor-advised fund operates as a specialized giving account sponsored by a public charity. The process is straightforward but incredibly powerful for tax planning:

  • You contribute assets such as cash, stock, or real estate.
  • You claim an immediate charitable deduction for the tax year of the gift.
  • The assets are invested, growing tax-free over time.
  • You recommend grants to specific operating charities at your own pace.

This structure allows taxpayers to separate the timing of their tax deduction from the timing of the actual charitable payout. It is especially useful for high-income earners looking to "bunch" several years of giving into a single, high-tax year. This flexibility is a primary reason why these accounts held over $326 billion in assets nationwide as of 2024.

A $21 Million Dispute Over Donor Intent

Two professionals shaking hands over a financial agreement

The current conversation surrounding control stems from a lawsuit involving a Colorado-based charitable foundation, WaterStone. According to court filings, Philip Peterson assumed the role of successor advisor for an account originally established by his late father.

Peterson claims the sponsoring charity severed communication and refused to entertain his grant recommendations. Conversely, WaterStone argues that the foundational donor agreement granted their organization absolute discretion over the funds, meaning they are under no legal obligation to heed the donor's or successor's advice.

This high-stakes case is being closely watched by tax professionals and estate planners. It tests the limits of what authority an advisor—especially a second-generation one—actually retains after the initial contribution is finalized.

Advised, Not Controlled: Navigating the Tax Reality

The core issue in the WaterStone lawsuit reveals the defining feature of a DAF: these accounts are donor-advised, not donor-controlled. To secure the immediate tax deduction, the gift must be irrevocable. When you move assets into the fund, legal ownership officially transfers to the sponsoring charity.

While reputable sponsors almost always follow their donors' recommendations, those recommendations remain strictly advisory. The charity holds the ultimate legal authority.

This distinction is particularly important for families designing multi-generational estate plans. While you might intend for your children to manage your charitable legacy, institutional policies vary wildly. Some sponsors welcome multiple generations of successor advisors, while others enforce strict termination policies upon the original donor's death. Knowing the exact terms of your agreement is non-negotiable.

Crucial Questions for Your Sponsoring Charity

Before committing significant wealth to any sponsor, we recommend asking a few direct questions to protect your philanthropic vision:

  • What are your specific policies regarding successor advisors?
  • How many generations can hold advisory privileges?
  • Is it possible to transfer the fund to a different sponsoring organization later?
  • Under what specific circumstances would you deny a grant recommendation?
  • What happens to the remaining assets if no successor advisor is named?

Never assume all sponsors operate under the same rulebook.

Protecting Your Charitable Legacy in Georgia

Despite this legal friction, DAFs remain one of the most powerful tools for managing high-income years, avoiding capital gains on appreciated stock, and simplifying your charitable footprint. Recent tax shifts have only amplified the demand for robust charitable planning strategies.

The key takeaway isn't to abandon these funds, but to approach them with clear expectations. You receive the upfront tax benefit, but you forfeit legal control. If you are building a long-term charitable strategy in Tucker or the broader Atlanta metro, Michael Robertson and the team at Robertson Financial Group are here to help. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and ensure your wealth creates the exact impact you envision.

Share this article...

Sign up for our newsletter.

Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and business tips & insights you need to know.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

We care about the protection of your data.